EDUCATION NOTEBOOK:
School Choice: The Democrats' Dilemma
By Dan Lips and Evan Feinberg
President Nixon opened China, President Clinton delivered
welfare reform, and it may take a Democratic presidential candidate
to buck that party's history and pave the way for widespread
parental choice in education. But if parents are hoping for such a
conversion during the 2008 presidential campaign, they shouldn't
get their hopes up.
The leading Democratic candidates recently made a pilgrimage to
the National Education Association's annual convention, where each
delivered remarks geared to win favor with the powerful union and
its 3.2 million members.
All of the candidates stayed on script, highlighting their
commitment to public education and strong opposition to school
choice. Former Senator John Edwards told the teachers that "your
agenda is basically my agenda" and "we should not drain money away
from public schools through vouchers." Not to be outdone, New
Mexico Governor Bill Richardson proclaimed his strong opposition to
school choice: "Let me tell you right now, vouchers are not the
answer! I've never supported vouchers and I will not support
vouchers in the future!"
Some had hoped that Illinois Senator Barak Obama might embrace
school vouchers as part of his sometimes centrist-leaning campaign.
Last year, he cosponsored legislation with Senator Jim DeMint to
give disadvantaged high school students scholarships for
post-secondary education, a modest form of school choice. But hopes
that Senator Obama would go further were doused at the NEA
convention when he told the delegates he was "committed to fixing
our public schools instead of abandoning them and passing out
vouchers."
And no one was surprised by the comments from Senator Hillary
Clinton, long a critic of school choice. Last year, she argued that
school vouchers would lead to some children attending "the school
of the White Supremacist" or the "school of the Jihad." This year,
she promised the NEA delegates that she would fight vouchers "with
every breath in my body."
On other issues - like higher education, housing subsidies, and
food stamps - Democrats support and push for increased funding for
vouchers that deliver public subsidies directly to the individual,
but when it comes to K-12 education, vouchers are usually off
limits.
One reason is the party's relationship with powerful special
interest groups like the National Education Association, whose
members are among its most loyal contributors and volunteers.
Congressional Quarterly reports that 93 percent of the
NEA's PAC contributions have gone to Democrats since 1980.
But a new organization, Democrats for Education
Reform (DFER), was recently launched in hopes of transforming
the party's hostility to reforms like school choice. The group's
founders include a former D.C. city council member who supported
school vouchers and a former Teach for America employee. "There are
millions of kids out there who are being failed by the system, and
our party is looking the other way," explained one of the founders
to Philanthropy Magazine. "It's morally
bankrupt and politically suicidal, and you can quote me on
that."
The group has avoided taking a position on school vouchers, but
its Executive Director, Joe Williams, has previously written about
of the need for greater parental empowerment, highlighting the
success of Milwaukee's school voucher program in his book Cheating Our Kids: How Politics and Greed Ruin
Education.
DFER is currently focusing on specific reform initiatives in New
Jersey and New York, and success is not out of the question. Unlike
their party's presidential contenders, Democrats at the state and
local level are embracing school choice in increasing numbers.
But the group hopes to influence the national debate in the
future. If it succeeds in persuading more Democrats to reject the
teachers unions' anti-school choice orthodoxy, parental choice
initiatives could proliferate across the country.
One day, Americans might even see a leading Democrat
presidential candidate champion the need for widespread school
choice to give all families the opportunity to choose a quality
school for their children. Unfortunately, it doesn't look like 2008
will be the year.
Dan Lips is Education Analyst and Evan Feinberg is
Domestic Policy Research Assistant at the Heritage Foundation,
www.Heritage.org.