Remarks made at The Heritage
Foundation on December 12, 2002
Thank you for inviting me here to discuss the hopes
and aspirations we share with the peoples of the Middle East. I'd
also like to welcome our other distinguished guests from the
diplomatic corps, congressional staff, the NGO community, and the
private sector. Thank you for making the time to come today. It is
fitting that we meet at the Heritage Foundation. For the Heritage
Foundation's vision to build a country "where freedom, opportunity,
prosperity, and civil society flourish" is the same vision we share
with the peoples of the Middle East for their countries.
Ladies and gentlemen, the Middle East is a
vast region of vast importance to the American people. Millions of
us worship in churches, mosques, and synagogues, professing the
three great faiths that were born in the lands between the
Mediterranean Sea and the Persian Gulf.
Our
language and traditions are filled with references to Jerusalem,
Bethlehem, and Mecca. Our phone books list names such as Mousavi,
Levy, and Shaheen that speak of deep family roots in the Middle
East. Our farmers grow wheat, and our workers make airplanes,
computers, and many other products that we sell to the countries of
the region. We, in turn, benefit from traded goods and investment
from the Middle East.
And,
tragically, thousands of our countrymen and women died on September
11, 2001, at the hands of terrorists born and radicalized there.
Recognizing the region's importance, we have for half a century and
more devoted our blood and our treasure to helping the peoples and
governments of the Middle East.
Indeed, my own career in public service
has been shaped by events there. I was privileged to be Chairman of
the Joint Chiefs of Staff when the United States led the
international coalition, including many Arab countries, that
evicted the Iraqi invaders from Kuwait. Today, as Secretary of
State, the Middle East requires a great deal of my attention. As a
government, our Middle East policy has emphasized winning the war
on terrorism, disarming Iraq, and bringing the Arab-Israeli
conflict to an end.
The
war on terrorism is not confined to the Middle East, of course, but
our friends there have a particularly important stake in it. Many
have suffered the scourge of terrorism first hand. I am pleased
that our friends have stepped up to the challenge by extending
basing rights for Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan,
exchanging intelligence and law enforcement information, arresting
suspected terrorists, and clamping down on terrorist financing.
With
the countries of the Middle East, our friends and allies, and the
community of nations, we must also deal with the grave and growing
danger posed by the Iraqi regime of Saddam Hussein. By unanimously
passing Resolution 1441, the United Nations Security Council has
offered Iraq a final opportunity to meet its obligations. The Iraqi
regime can either disarm or be disarmed. The choice is theirs, but
it can no longer be postponed.
We
also have a deep and abiding national interest in bringing the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict to an end. With our friends in the
region and the international community, we are working to bring
about a lasting peace based on President Bush's vision of two
states living side-by-side in peace and security. This peace will
require from the Palestinians a new and different leadership, new
institutions, and an end to terror and violence. As the
Palestinians make progress in this direction, Israel will also be
required to make hard choices, including an end to all settlement
construction activity, consistent with the Mitchell Report.
As
President Bush has stated, with intensive effort by all, the
creation of a democratic, viable Palestine is possible in 2005. Our
ultimate goal is a just and comprehensive Arab-Israeli settlement
in which all the peoples of the region are accepted as neighbors,
living in peace and security.
These challenges have been at the
forefront of America's Middle East policy, and with good reason.
Each profoundly affects our national interest and the interests of
the peoples who call the Middle East home. We remain deeply
committed to meeting each of these challenges with energy and
determination.
Closing the "Hope Gap"
At
the same time, it has become increasingly clear that we must
broaden our approach to the region if we are to achieve success. In
particular, we must give sustained and energetic attention to
economic, political, and educational reform. We must work with
peoples and governments to close the gulf between expectation and
reality that Jordan's Queen Rania has so eloquently called the
"hope gap."
The
spread of democracy and free markets, fueled by the wonders of the
technological revolution, has created a dynamo that can generate
prosperity and human well-being on an unprecedented scale. But this
revolution has largely left the Middle East behind.
Throughout history, the countries of the
Middle East have made invaluable contributions to the arts and
sciences. Today, however, too many people there lack the very
political and economic freedom, empowerment of women, and modern
education they need to prosper in the 21st century. The 2002 Arab
Human Development Report, written by leading Arab scholars and
issued by the United Nations, identified a fundamental choice
between "inertia [and] an Arab renaissance that will build a
prosperous future for all Arabs." These are not my words. They come
from Arab experts who have looked deeply into the issues. They are
based on the stark facts.
Some
14 million Arab adults lack the jobs they need to put food on their
tables, roofs over their heads, and hope in their hearts. Some 50
million more Arab young people will enter the already crowded job
market over the next eight years.
But
economies are not creating enough jobs. Growth is weak. The GDP of
260 million Arabs is already less than that of 40 million Spaniards
and falling even further behind. Add in the production of Iran's 67
million people, and the total is still only two-thirds of Italy's.
Internally, many economies are stifled by regulation and cronyism.
They lack transparency and are closed to entrepreneurship,
investment, and trade.
The
countries of the Middle East are also largely absent from world
markets. They generate barely one percent of the world's non-oil
exports. Only ten Middle Eastern countries belong to the World
Trade Organization. The region's governments are now recognizing,
as Egypt's President Hosni Mubarak has warned, that "giving a boost
to exports is a matter of life or death."
A
shortage of economic opportunities is a ticket to despair. Combined
with rigid political systems, it is a dangerous brew indeed. Along
with freer economies, many of the peoples of the Middle East need a
stronger political voice. We reject the condescending notion that
freedom will not grow in the Middle East or that there is any
region of the world that cannot support democracy.
President Bush gave voice to the yearnings
of people everywhere when he declared, in his West Point address,
that "when it comes to the common rights and needs of men and
women, there is no clash of civilizations. The requirements of
freedom apply fully to Africa and Latin America and the entire
Islamic world."
Given a choice between tyranny and
freedom, people choose freedom. We need look only to the streets of
Kabul, filled with people celebrating the end of Taliban rule last
year. There are rays of hope in the Middle East as well. Countries
such as Bahrain, Qatar, and Morocco have embarked on bold political
reforms. Civic organizations are increasingly active in many Arab
countries, working on bread-and-butter issues such as securing
badly needed identity cards for women.
We
are also seeing an explosion of media outlets, from satellite
television stations to weekly tabloids. Though some still do not
live up to their responsibility to deliver responsible coverage and
factual information, they are making information available to more
people than ever before. Still, too many Middle Easterners are
ruled by closed political systems. Too many governments curb the
institutions of civil society as a threat, rather than welcome them
as the basis for a free, dynamic, and hopeful society. And the
language of hate, exclusion, and incitement to violence is still
all too common.
As
Morocco's King Mohammed told his country's parliament two years
ago, "to achieve development, democracy, and modernization, it is
necessary to improve and strengthen political parties, trade
unions, associations, and the media, and to enlarge the scope of
participation."
Finally, too many of the region's children
lack the knowledge to take advantage of a world of economic and
political freedom. Ten million school-age children are at home, at
work, or on the streets instead of in class. Some 65 million of
their parents cannot read or write, let alone help them with their
lessons. Barely one person out of a hundred has access to a
computer. Of those, only half can reach the wider world via the
Internet.
Even
when children do go to school, they often fail to learn the skills
they need to succeed in the 21st century. "Education" too often
means rote learning rather than the creative, critical thinking
essential for success in our globalizing world. The authors of the
Arab Development Report have found that "education has begun to
lose its significant role as a means of achieving social
advancement in Arab countries, turning instead into a means of
perpetuating social stratification and poverty." That is a telling
indictment and a call to action.
There is a constant theme running through
these challenges, and that is the marginalization of women in many
Middle Eastern countries. More than half of the Arab world's women
are illiterate. They suffer more from unemployment and lack of
economic opportunity. Women also make up a smaller proportion of
members of parliament in Arab countries than in any other region in
the world.
Until the countries of the Middle East
unleash the abilities and potential of their women, they will not
build a future of hope. Any approach to the Middle East that
ignores its political, economic, and educational underdevelopment
will be built upon sand.
Laying the Foundation of Hope
It
is time to lay a firm foundation of hope. I am announcing today an
initiative that places the United States firmly on the side of
change, of reform, and of a modern future for the Middle East.
During last March's visit by President Mubarak to Washington,
President Bush asked me to head a new American government effort to
support the peoples and governments of the Middle East in their
efforts to meet these pressing human challenges.
I am
pleased to announce the initial results of our work: an innovative
set of programs and a framework for future cooperation that we call
the U.S.-Middle East Partnership Initiative. The U.S.-Middle East
Partnership Initiative is a bridge between the United States and
the Middle East, between our governments and our peoples, that
spans the hope gap with energy, ideas, and funding.
Our
Partnership Initiative is a continuation, and a deepening, of our
longstanding commitment to working with all the peoples of the
Middle East to improve their daily lives and help them face the
future with hope. Just as our decision to rejoin UNESCO is a symbol
of our commitment to advancing human rights and tolerance and
learning, so this Initiative is a concrete demonstration of our
commitment to human dignity in the Middle East.
We
are initially dedicating $29 million to get this Initiative off to
a strong start. Working with Congress, we will seek significant
additional funding for next year. These funds will be over and
above the more than $1 billion we provide in economic assistance to
the Arab world every year.
Our
initiative rests on three pillars. We will engage with public and
private-sector groups to bridge the jobs gap with economic reform,
business investment, and private-sector development. We will
partner with community leaders to close the freedom gap with
projects to strengthen civil society, expand political
participation, and lift the voices of women. And we will work with
parents and educators to bridge the knowledge gap with better
schools and more opportunities for higher education.
Ladies and gentlemen, hope begins with a
paycheck. And that requires a vibrant economy. Through the
U.S.-Middle East Partnership Initiative, we will work with
governments to establish economic rules and regulations that will
attract foreign investment and allow the private sector to
flourish.
We
will help small and medium-sized businesses gain access to the
life-blood of capital. As a first step, I am pleased to announce
that we will establish Enterprise Funds for the Middle East,
modeled after the successful Polish-American Enterprise Fund, to
begin investing in promising new businesses. We will also help more
countries share in the bounty of the global economy. That means
offering aspiring World Trade Organization members like Saudi
Arabia, Algeria, Lebanon, and Yemen technical assistance to meet
the WTO's membership criteria.
It
means building upon our successful Free Trade Agreement with Jordan
by beginning FTA negotiations with Morocco. And it means continuing
to work with countries like Egypt and Bahrain to explore ways to
enhance our bilateral economic trade relationships, including
through possible free trade agreements.
Open
economies require open political systems. So the second pillar of
our Partnership Initiative will support citizens across the region
who are claiming their political voices. We began the first pilot
project in this area last month, when we brought a delegation of 55
Arab women political leaders to the United States to observe our
mid-term elections.
I
had a very good meeting with this remarkable group during their
stay in Washington, and I was inspired by their energy and
commitment. They put tough questions to me, and we debated the
issues as people do in free societies. These women were proud of
their heritage and spoke eloquently of their dreams of a world
where their children could live in peace. They told of their hopes
to see an end to the conflicts that cripple their region, including
their expectations for America's role. They talked about how they
want control over their own lives and destinies. And they asked to
know more about American democracy and how to make their own voices
more effective.
Increased political participation also
requires strengthening the civic institutions that protect
individual rights and provide opportunities for participation.
Through our Partnership Initiative we will support these efforts.
To be effective, free economies and open political systems need
educated citizens, so the third pillar of the U.S.-Middle East
Partnership Initiative will focus on education reform.
Our
programs will emphasize the education of girls. An Egyptian poet
once wrote that "A mother is a school. Empower her and you empower
a great nation." He was right. When girls' literacy rates improve,
all the other important indicators of development in a country
improve as well. We will provide scholarships to keep girls in
school and expand literacy for girls and women. More broadly, we
will work with parents and educators to strengthen local and
parental oversight of school systems.
In
each of these three areas, we are committed to genuine, two-way
partnership--partnership with the citizens and countries of the
region, with Congress, and even with other donors as we implement
this agenda. The U.S.-Middle East Partnership Initiative is one of
the most challenging undertakings that we and our friends in the
region have ever considered. We should be realistic about the
obstacles on the road ahead, about the time it will take to see
real change take root, and about the limited role that outsiders
can play. We should understand that genuine Middle Eastern interest
must drive this initiative, and only Middle Eastern engagement will
sustain it.
But
we should also avoid resigning ourselves to low expectations. As
the ferment in the region shows, the peoples of the Middle East
themselves are seized with these issues. We are not starting from
scratch. We are already working successfully with a broad array of
partners. For example, just last month we announced the
establishment of the LEAD Foundation, in which the United States
Agency for International Development is partnering with the World
Bank and the Egyptian private sector to support micro-enterprise
lending in Egypt.
In
addition, through our Partnership for Learning, we are already
engaged with the countries of the region on teacher training,
English-language instruction, and other programs to strengthen
their educational systems. Indeed, an important part of our work
will involve reviewing our existing programs to learn from them and
make sure our assistance touches as many lives as possible. Nor are
we advocating a "one size fits all" approach. The region is much
too diverse for that. We will be on the ground listening and
working to make sure our programs are tailored to meet the needs of
people where they live their lives.
With
the U.S.-Middle East Partnership Initiative, we recognize that hope
built from economic, political, and educational opportunity is
critical to the success of all of our efforts. And that the success
of these other efforts is, in turn, essential to creating hope. In
my travels throughout the Middle East, in public and in private
life, I have seen first hand the energy, creativity, and dedication
of parents as they try to build a better future for their children.
But I have also seen their frustration when progress is so
painfully slow. We must move faster. We will move faster.
Through the U.S.-Middle East Partnership
Initiative, we are adding hope to the U.S.-Middle East agenda. We
are pledging our energy, our abilities, and our idealism to bring
hope to all of God's children who call the Middle East home.
--The Honorable Colin L. Powell is the
U.S. Secretary of State.