WASHINGTON, APRIL 18, 2000-While the current
education debate focuses on money, a new study of low-income
schools finds the key to academic excellence is not dollars, but
educators who instill a passion for achievement and refuse to
accept failure.
In "No Excuses:
Lessons from 21 High-Performing, High-Poverty Schools"
(Washington, D.C., The Heritage Foundation, 121 pages), Samuel
Casey Carter, a Bradley fellow at the Washington-based Heritage
Foundation, highlights schools whose predominantly low-income
Hispanic and African-American students score significantly above
the national average in core subjects. The common thread:
principals and teachers who demand excellence and reject the notion
that poor kids can't learn.
Although at least 75 percent of the students in these schools
come from low-income families, they score in the 65th percentile or
higher on national exams, according to the report published today
(see: www.noexcuses.org). Nationwide, schools with 75 percent
low-income students typically score below the 35th percentile on
national exams.
"No Excuses principals reject the ideology of victimhood that
dominates most public discussion of race and academic achievement,"
writes Adam Meyerson, Heritage vice president for educational
affairs, in the foreword. "They do not dumb down tests and courses
for black and Hispanic children; instead they prove that children
of all races and income levels can take tough courses and
succeed."
But despite their accomplishments, these principals should not
be viewed as isolated superheroes, Carter writes. Instead, they
show what would be possible if public-school systems began to
encourage and reward this level of success-success that could be
replicated at schools nationwide. Despite large class sizes (35 per
classroom in one school) and shoestring budgets, these educators
produce outstanding students, undermining the pervasive myth that
only "rich kids" can do well in school.
Take Arkansas' Portland Elementary, located in a remote region
of the Mississippi Delta. Portland is home to fewer than 600
people, most of whom make their living working cotton fields and
catfish farms. The nearest airport is more than an hour-and-a-half
away. When Principal Ernest Smith arrived five years ago, half the
students in the 4th, 5th and 6th grades were scoring two years or
more below grade level.
Today, every student in those grades is performing at grade
level or above. In 1999, the 6th graders scored in the 72nd
percentile in reading and 84th in math. "I tell the school the
100th percentile is our goal," Smith says.
For "No Excuses" educators, high expectations aren't enough.
Schools must create an atmosphere of success, holding teachers
accountable for student achievement, Carter says. For successful
principals believe teacher quality supersedes seniority, and they
personally recruit the best instructors and make sure their hires
understand the need to produce top-notch results.
"In my final interview with the candidate, I lay down the law,"
says Principal Gregory Hodge of New York City's Frederick Douglass
Academy. "As quickly as you're hired, you can be fired. If you
don't perform-you're gone." When prospective teachers ask him how
they'll be judged, Hodge replies: "How will you evaluate your
students? Through test scores. That's how I'll evaluate you-through
their test scores."
The hard work pays off. In 1998, 93 percent of Hodge's students
who took the U.S. History Regents passed, compared with 54 percent
across the city. In English and pre-calculus, his students had
passing rates of 88 percent and 87 percent, respectively. In the
Global History Regents, a two-year survey course of world
civilizations considered by many to be New York state's most
challenging exam, 95 percent passed, compared with 54 percent
citywide.
But to produce a "No Excuses" school, hard work must be married
to freedom, Carter says. The track record produced by the men and
women at these schools shows that educators must be free to decide
how to spend their money, whom to hire and what to teach. It's this
kind of flexibility that allows them to succeed. "Great principals
often are mavericks who buck the system or low-flyers who get the
job done quietly," he writes.
Alyson Barillari of Fourteenth Avenue School in Newark, N.J., is
one of those who know how to get the job done. Her student body, 98
percent black and 98 percent low-income, includes a large number of
special education students with severe physical and mental
handicaps. Yet for the last several years, Barillari's regular
education students have posted mean scores above the 90th
percentile on the Stanford-9 achievement test.
Educators frequently cite a lack of parental involvement to
explain student failure. That's not a problem among the "No
Excuses" principals, who insist on having a home environment
conducive to education. To ensure that the home is a "center of
learning," these schools establish contracts with parents, who
pledge to support the school's efforts by checking homework and
reading to their children. At Cascade Elementary in Atlanta, for
example, parents are even required to have their children in bed by
9 p.m.
Hard work breeds success, these principals say. The students at
the Marcus Garvey School in Los Angeles, for example, routinely
score two or more years above grade level in core subjects. In
1999, three Garvey 7th graders began attending West Los Angeles
Junior College after testing at the post-secondary level in all
subjects. Advanced math is customary: Pre-schoolers add and
subtract two-digit numbers, four-year-olds know the multiplication
tables, and 4th graders study elementary algebra.
Such dedication from educators can turn low-performing schools
around in relatively short order. When Principal Alfonso Jessie Jr.
came to Atlanta's Cascade Elementary four years ago, the 5th
graders were scoring in the 44th percentile in reading and in the
37th in math. In 1999, they scored in the 82nd percentile in
reading and the 74th in math. Students in the other grades also
improved, leading Cascade to be ranked 7th out of the 1,064 schools
in the state.
"No Excuses" principals also emphasize the importance of test
taking. Principal Patsy Burks at Detroit's Owen Elementary directs
a team approach to testing-for example, by having the 4th grade
teacher help the 3rd grade teacher prepare the end-of-the-year exam
for his or her future students. It works: 94 percent of Owen 4th
graders passed the state math exam last year (compared to 49
percent of 4th graders citywide), while the 5th graders posted a
mean score of 98th percentile in reading and 90th in math.
The education establishment can learn a lot from the "No
Excuses" principals, Adam Meyerson says. "Finding the right
principals, who in turn will find the right teachers, may be more
important than reducing class size, modernizing school facilities,
or any of the conventional nostroms for improving public
education," he writes. "One of the nation's highest priorities
should be to learn from the best practices of these high-performing
schools and to insist that all schools serving low-income children
aspire to the No Excuses standard of excellence."