WASHINGTON, APRIL 21, 2000-In a country where
Internet-ready computers are now cheaper than televisions-and even
given away for free-the notion that a digital divide separates the
technological "haves" and "have nots" doesn't compute, says a new
Heritage Foundation study.
"Today's dynamic market for personal computers and access to the
Internet is generating a 'digital deluge' of opportunity for
Americans to get connected," says Adam Thierer, Heritage's Walker
fellow in economic policy studies. "Free computers and inexpensive
computing technologies are filling any digital divide that
remains."
Thierer examined the prices of Internet-ready computers at 18
different vendors and found four machines priced under $400 and one
machine priced under $300. Even the cheapest machine was more than
adequate for most of today's computing needs (with a 466 megahurtz
processor, 32 megabytes of RAM, and a 56K modem). By comparison,
the price of a 25-to-27 inch color television at the vendors
surveyed by Thierer ranged from a low of $288 (Wal-Mart) to a high
of $402 (Circuit City), with an average price of $332.
"If Americans can purchase an internet-ready PC for less than
the cost of many TVs, just how real is the digital divide?" Thierer
asks. "After all, 99 percent of all Americans-including 97 percent
of all poor households-now own a television set."
Thierer also notes that a number of companies are now giving
away "free" computers if the customer signs up for Internet
service, usually for 36 months. At the six companies Thierer
surveyed, the highest monthly fee was $29.99 and the lowest a mere
$21.88. "With the 'free PC' era now in full swing," he says, "it
would seem there is little reason to create a national computer
entitlement program," a reference to a proposal to give low-income
families a $500 tax credit toward the cost of a PC.
And even if computers remain too pricey for some families,
Thierer says emerging technologies are rendering the PC irrelevant.
He sees particular promise in hybrid systems known as "Internet
appliances" or "dumb terminals"-stripped-down machines, often
costing less than $99, that provide instant Internet access without
the need of a hard drive.
"If Americans really want a personal computer and access to the
Internet, they can get them at very little cost," Thierer says.
"Expensive federal entitlement programs will not facilitate this
process. In fact, they could make things worse by putting pressure
on computer prices to hold steady or increase."