On his seven-day
tour of sub-Saharan Africa, President Bush must take with him
a new vision for Africa, based on the universal principles of
economic liberty, political freedom and respect for the rule of
law.
But it must also
be a vision backed by a greater willingness on the part of
Washington to actively shape the future of the continent, working
in conjunction with her key allies in London and other European
capitals.
Issues of
Concern
The President's tour comes at a time when the United States is
facing increasing international pressure to play a more prominent
role in the world's most troubled continent. The civil wars in
Liberia and the Congo, the specter of tyranny and man-made famine
in Zimbabwe, the spread of the AIDS epidemic, and the rising threat
of international terrorism in East Africa, are all issues of
mounting concern to Washington.
Much of modern-day
Africa continues to be blighted by poverty, disease, misrule,
corruption and inter-tribal rivalry. Sub-Saharan Africa remains the
world's poorest region, with a GDP per capita income of just $568,
and an average life expectancy of only 48 years. An estimated 40
million Africans are infected with HIV/AIDS, and a further 20
million have died from the disease.
Key Recommendations for President
Bush
The Bush Administration has begun
to offer some real solutions to the continent's vast problems, and
this tour is a potent symbol of Washington's commitment to a
continent with huge potential but which is all too often forgotten
or at best ignored. A great deal more though will need to be
achieved in the coming years if America is to play a lead role in
shaping Africa's destiny.
The President's
policy on Africa should be driven by a clear set of principles and
priorities:
Security
Co-operation to Combat Terrorism
The Bush Administration should increase its efforts to
co-ordinate security measures with African countries at risk from
terrorism. The recently unveiled $100 million US counter-terrorism
package for East Africa was a welcome step in the right direction.
The al-Qaeda threat continues to grow in countries such as Kenya
and Tanzania, and stronger measures will need to be taken by the
United States in the region. The White House should consider the
use of covert operations and precision strikes to target al-Qaeda
cells operating in neighbouring Somalia, a failed state that has
become a fertile breeding ground for Islamic terrorists. The United
States must be prepared to take pre-emptive action if intelligence
sources indicate that terrorists are preparing to use weapons of
mass destruction. Where the terrorist threat is immediate and
overwhelming, pre-emptive strikes are justified on grounds of
self-defense.
Zero Tolerance
for Dictatorships
Since the end of the colonial era, much of sub-Saharan Africa
has been a playground for spoilt despots wreaking havoc on their
fiefdoms. In this trip to Africa President Bush must declare an end
to the era of dictatorships. At the dawn of the 21st
Century it should not be acceptable for tyrants to terrorize
millions of their own citizens in the Middle East, Europe, Asia or
Africa. The Bush Administration should operate a zero tolerance
policy towards African dictatorships, imposing strict economic and
political sanctions against those regimes that tyrannize their
populations. In certain circumstances, particularly where the US
national interest is involved, the credible threat of military
force should be exercised.
Military
Intervention In Support of Vital Interests
In the 1990s the United States was largely content to take a
back-seat role in Africa. The US intervention in Somalia was
America's only significant involvement in the continent in that
decade. The ill-fated US military operation in Mogadishu weakened
the resolve of the Clinton Administration to take a more pro-active
role in Africa. Empty rhetoric about human rights replaced action
on the ground. The world's major powers stood by while a million
Tutsis were slaughtered by French-backed Hutus in Rwanda in
1994.
While Washington
should remain wary of the perils of nation-building, the US must
not be afraid to intervene militarily when vital national interests
are threatened, or when military force can be effectively used to
prevent genocide or other gross violations of human rights. The
West's failure to halt the genocide in Rwanda must never be
repeated. The US must work closely with its key ally Great Britain
and with other European nations in intervening where necessary and
feasible to stop genocide from taking place. The highly successful
British military operation in Sierra Leone should serve as a role
model for future intervention in Africa.
Although it may be
advantageous in certain instances for a UN Security Council mandate
to be sought for military intervention, US forces should not be
placed under UN command or control.
Expanding Free
Trade and Encouraging Good Governance
The United States is a major trading partner with sub-Saharan
Africa, with trade valued at nearly $24 billion in 2002. US direct
investment in the region amounts to $10 billion. The President must
call for the further lifting of barriers to trade with Africa, and
encourage the European Union and all developed nations to do the
same through the World Trade Organisation. Free trade remains one
of the keys to Africa's potential economic renaissance. As the
Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic Freedom demonstrates, there
is a direct correlation between open economies and economic
prosperity.
The President
should also encourage free trade agreements with African countries
with flourishing democracies and market economies. Washington
should press ahead with negotiations to sign a free trade agreement
(FTA) with the five members of the Southern African Customs Union
(SACU): South Africa, Namibia, Botswana, Lesotho and Swaziland.
However, it should be made clear that the speed of negotiations
with SACU will be linked to the pace of political reform in
neighbouring Zimbabwe.
At the same time,
the disbursement of development assistance in Africa must be linked
to good government. The $5 billion per annum Millennium Challenge
Account, launched by President Bush this year, is a bold proposal
aimed at encouraging potential aid recipients to implement
political and economic reform. The MCA is a revolutionary concept
which if successful should serve as a model for international aid
programs across the world.
Robust and
Pro-Active Africa Policy
In an increasingly globalised world, the United States and
other leading nations cannot afford to ignore Africa's problems.
The Bush Administration has shown a refreshing commitment to the
future of Africa and is beginning to demonstrate real leadership on
African issues internationally. President Bush's call for President
Charles Taylor to step down as leader of Liberia, and Secretary of
State Colin Powell's vociferous condemnation of the Zimbabwean
regime have sent shock waves through Africa.
Still more is
needed. The Bush Administration must adopt an even more robust and
pro-active Africa policy that places the United States at the
forefront of international efforts to deal with Africa's vast
problems. The US must play a key role in shaping Africa's future,
and in helping the continent to fulfill its huge potential.
Nile Gardiner
Ph.D. is Visiting Fellow in Anglo-American Security Policy at the
Heritage Foundation.
President
Bush's Africa Tour ~ July 7-12 2003
The President's
trip includes visits to English-speaking South Africa, Nigeria,
Botswana and Uganda, as well as Francophone Senegal. The highlight
of the trip will be the meeting in Pretoria between President Bush
and President Thabo Mbeki of South Africa, the continent's economic
and military powerhouse. Secretary of State Colin Powell, and
National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice will accompany the
President in South Africa.
| Botswana |
|
|
|
| Population: |
1.8 million |
| Head of State: |
President Festus Mogae |
| Location: |
Southern Africa |
| Key Issues for Bush: |
Economic growth; good governance; AIDS; Zimbabwe. |
Botswana is one of
Africa's most well run democracies, and was recently ranked the
least corrupt country in Africa by the World Economic Forum. The
world's largest diamond producer, it is also one of the most
prosperous nations on the continent. Economic growth has averaged
over 7 per cent per annum over the past 20 years, the most
spectacular record of any country in Africa. Botswana is one of
Africa's few middle-income countries, with a Gross National Income
(GNI) of $3,700 per capita. On the downside, 39% of adult
Botswanans are infected with HIV; life expectancy remains pitifully
low, at just 39 years for men, and 40 for women.
| Nigeria |
|
|
|
| Population: |
124 million |
| Head of State: |
President Olusegun Obasanjo |
| Location: |
West Africa |
| Key Issues for Bush: |
Liberia; corruption; foreign debt; ethnic/religious
violence. |
President Bush
will be looking to Nigeria to help end the brutal conflict in
nearby Liberia. Domestically, President Obasanjo faces mounting
economic problems as well as sectarian violence in parts of the
country. Ethnic and religious tensions remain high, and more than
10,000 people have been killed in religious and ethnic clashes over
the past four years.
Nigeria has sub-Saharan Africa's largest population and second
largest economy, in addition to being the world's sixth largest
exporter of oil, yet per capita income remains extremely low, at
just $290. Two thirds of the population lives below the poverty
line, and the average Nigerian is now worse off than he was before
independence from Great Britain in 1960. Nigeria is heavily in
debt, and owes over $28 billion to foreign governments.
Corruption continues to blight Nigerian society on a vast scale,
acting as a major deterrent to foreign direct investment.
Transparency International has rated Nigeria one of the two most
corrupt countries in the world.
| Senegal |
|
|
|
| Population: |
10 million |
| Head of State: |
President Aboulaye Wade |
| Location: |
West Africa |
| Key Issues for Bush: |
Good governance; investment; foreign debt. |
Senegal is regarded as one of
Africa's most promising emerging democracies. It has over 40
political parties and a solid constitution with entrenched civil
liberties. The election of Aboulaye Wade as President in 2000
brought to an end 40 years of one-party Socialist rule. The country
continues though to be plagued by poverty, illiteracy, and a
foreign debt estimated to be 71% of GDP.
| South Africa |
|
|
|
| Population: |
45 million |
| Head of State: |
President Thabo Mbeki |
| Location: |
Southern Africa |
| Key Issues for Bush: |
Zimbabwe; trade and investment; HIV/AIDS |
President Bush's discussions with his South African counterpart are
likely to be dominated by the political and humanitarian crisis in
Zimbabwe. The turmoil in neighbouring Zimbabwe is threatening to
have a major destabilizing effect on South Africa and the region.
An estimated two million Zimbabweans have fled to South Africa, and
regional instability has acted as a major deterrent to foreign
investors. However, there is little sign that Pretoria is willing
to deal with the crisis. President Mbeki has come under increasing
criticism for his controversial policy of 'silent engagement' with
the Mugabe regime, and is seemingly content to pursue a strategy of
appeasement towards the Zimbabwean government.
Relations between Washington and Pretoria have been damaged in
recent weeks by South Africa's criticism of US policy in Iraq.
Former President Nelson Mandela remains an outspoken critic of
President Bush.
| Uganda |
|
|
|
| Population: |
26 million |
| Head of State: |
President Yoweri Museveni |
| Location: |
East Africa |
| Key Issues for Bush: |
HIV/AIDS |
President Bush has pledged $15 billion for fighting AIDS over the
next five years in Africa and the Caribbean. Bush Administration
officials have cited the Uganda model as a shining example for the
rest of Africa to follow. The Ugandan government has led the way in
combating the spread of AIDS through its highly successful ABC
policy. While AIDS has continued to rise in much of the continent,
the HIV rate of infection actually fell in Uganda from 6.9% in 1999
to 6.1% in 2002. Nearly a million Ugandans died of the disease
between 1982 and 2002, reducing life expectancy there to just 38
years by 1997.