President George
Bush today meets with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak at Bush's
ranch in Crawford, Texas, in the first of three summits with Middle
Eastern leaders over the next ten days. Israeli Prime Minister
Ariel Sharon is due at the White House on April 14, and Jordan's
King Abdallah follows him on April 21. These summits come against
the backdrop of the deteriorating situation in Iraq, but each
meeting is likely to focus primarily on the Arab-Israeli conflict,
which also has deteriorated since the breakdown of the Oslo peace
negotiations and the onset of the Palestinian intifada in September
2000. The President has the opportunity to leverage Israel's
proposed withdrawal from Gaza to restart the stalled peace process;
though the diplomacy will be difficult, he should attempt to
achieve this end.
Sharon's
proposal-that Israel unilaterally withdraw from all 17 Israeli
settlements in the Gaza strip-will be on the agenda of all three
summits. This surprising initiative, announced last December, is a
radical and risky move in the midst of continued diplomatic
stalemate with Yasser Arafat's Palestinian Authority. The Israeli
Prime Minister has opted to pursue a unilateral withdrawal because
he, understandably, has concluded that Israel does not have a
reliable Palestinian partner for peace. Arafat has sabotaged every
agreement that he has made with Israel to date and cannot be
trusted in any future negotiations.
The challenge for
the Bush Administration is to transform the withdrawal-which could
plunge Gaza into anarchy and strengthen the power of Hamas, an
Islamic extremist terrorist organization-into a stepping-stone
towards renewed negotiations under the road map peace plan to end
Palestinian terrorism. To stabilize the situation in Gaza, the
United States needs to work closely with Egypt, which can play a
much stronger role in restraining Palestinian terrorism.
The Mubarak
Summit
Egyptian President
Mubarak has rejected Israel's tentative requests to fill the power
vacuum in Gaza with Egyptian troops, but he has agreed to train and
advise Palestinian security forces to help them maintain order and
restrain terrorism after the Israeli withdrawal. This is start, but
it is not enough. Merely assisting the Palestinian security forces
will not necessarily help because they remain under the control of
Arafat, who remains wedded to terrorism against Israelis.
President Bush
should press the Egyptians to help marginalize Arafat and build a
Palestinian Authority that is untainted by terrorism and
corruption. The President should also stress that the development
of a Hamas-dominated Gaza mini-state is not in Egypt's national
interests. Hamas is an offshoot of Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood, an
Islamist movement outlawed in Egypt due to its past attempts to
overthrow the state. If Hamas takes control of Gaza, it will
undoubtedly attempt to export Islamic extremism into Egypt, as well
as terrorism into Israel.
The President
should also urge the Egyptians to do more combat arms smuggling
operations that have moved increasingly dangerous weapons and
military supplies-including shoulder-fired anti-aircraft
missiles-across Egypt's border into Gaza. The Israelis have found
at least 70 tunnels in the last ten years. Some of these could not
have been built without the passive acquiescence-if not the active
cooperation-of Egyptian officials. Cairo claims that it does
not condone the tunnels and can do little more to stop the
smuggling. President Bush should insist that the Egyptians redouble
their efforts to halt smuggling, and he should offer American
technical assistance in finding and destroying the tunnels.
Another topic for
discussion at the Mubarak summit will be the Bush Administration's
Greater Middle East Initiative, slated to be unveiled at the G-8
summit in June. The Egyptians, like many Arab allies of the United
States, fear that calls from the West for rapid democratic reforms
will lead to political instability. Cairo convened a conference of
hundreds of Arab human rights groups and nongovernmental
organizations in Alexandria last month to issue a declaration on
political, economic, and social reforms-and partially to
diplomatically preempt the Greater Middle East Initiative. While
this declaration stressed educational reforms, equality for women,
and free market economic reforms, it also called for caution on
democratic reforms
President Bush
should welcome the Egyptian initiative and reassure Mubarak that
America's push for democracy will not threaten its Arab allies. But
the President should also stress that Egypt's cautious economic
reforms have not gone far enough. He should encourage Cairo to
resume long-stalled efforts to privatize state enterprises,
encourage foreign investment, and free the Egyptian people to
participate in a market-driven economy.
The Sharon
Summit
Bush's summit with
Sharon on April 14 may determine the fate of Sharon's proposed
withdrawal from Gaza. The beleaguered Israeli leader-now facing
possible indictment for bribery in a real estate scandal-seeks
Bush's endorsement for his withdrawal plan to help sway his own
cabinet and the Likud Party, both of which oppose it. Because he
does not trust the Palestinians to deliver on possible concessions
for withdrawal, Sharon hopes instead to extract concessions from
Washington. He also seeks, reportedly, an American endorsement of
both a security fence that would block the infiltration of
Palestinian terrorists from the West Bank and Israel's permanent
retention of several large settlements in the West Bank.
The President will
likely counter with a push for a freeze on new settlements, the
immediate dismantling of unapproved settler outposts, and the
removal of four small settlements in the northern part of the West
Bank, all to demonstrate that the "Gaza First" withdrawal is not
really "Gaza Last." Egypt, Jordan, and other Arab states will help
stabilize Gaza only if they are assured that this is a step towards
a final settlement; they have no interest in merely helping Israel
consolidate control over the West Bank.
The President
needs to stress to Sharon that a Gaza withdrawal can be a good
prelude to negotiations but cannot, by itself, substitute for
negotiations. Left alone, Gaza will only fester, descend into
Islamic extremism, and become a haven for increasingly dangerous
Palestinian terrorism.
The Abdallah
Summit
The President's
April 21 summit with Jordan's King Abdallah is likely to focus on
Iraq as well as Arab-Israeli issues. Jordan shares a long,
permeable border with Iraq and is directly threatened by Iraqi
instability. The President should call for increased Jordanian
cooperation in halting the movement of Islamic extremists from
Jordan into Iraq and greater intelligence-sharing on the Ba'athist
forces and Islamic terrorists inside Iraq that pose a threat to
both countries. Jordan already has agreed to help train Iraqi
military and internal security forces. The President should also
explore the possibility that Jordan could dispatch advisers to
Iraqi institutions or even contribute troops to help stabilize the
country.
King Abdallah,
like President Mubarak, will seek American assurances that Israel's
withdrawal from Gaza does not mean an end to peace negotiations. As
with the previous two summits, the challenge for the President will
be to use the Israeli withdrawal as leverage for the resumption of
serious negotiations in the future, hopefully after Yasser Arafat
is no longer in a position to veto a genuine peace settlement.
James
Phillips is Research Fellow in the Kathryn and Shelby Cullom
Davis Institute for International Studies at The Heritage
Foundation.