On July 31, Uzbek
President Islam Karimov served notice on the Pentagon that the U.S.
should vacate the Karshi-Khanabad military base (K-2 in military
parlance) within six months. In the post- 9/11 era, this is the
first time that a U.S. ally has not only abandoned the
battlefield-as Spain did in Iraq-but also shown American servicemen
the door. After years of complaining that the United States has not
done enough to counter terrorist threats, Karimov did what his
Islamist foes have demanded all along: He demanded an end to the
American "infidel" presence in Uzbekistan.
Clinging to
Power. Karimov took this
drastic step because he believed that the U.S. policy of support
for democracy might lead to a "multicolor" revolution in
Uzbekistan, which is predominantly Muslim but has a secular
government. Indeed, Mr. Karimov's authoritarian practices, which
have left the population impoverished and intimidated, have
built up internal political pressure that could lead to a social
explosion and destabilization.
When Uzbek troops
killed hundreds of civilian protestors while trying to put down an
Islamist uprising in the city of Andijan on May 13, Washington
joined other Western governments in demanding an international
investigation. In response, Uzbekistan limited night flights at
K-2, which is located 90 miles north of the Afghanistan border.
When the United States supported the evacuation of Uzbek refugees
from camps in neighboring Kyrgyzstan to Romania, including
some suspected militants-that Karimov demanded be repatriated-the
curtain went down on K-2.
Geopolitical
Context. In July, the Shanghai
Cooperation Organization (SCO) demanded that the United States
provide a timetable for the withdrawal of its forces from
Central Asia. The SCO is a regional bloc dominated by Russia and
China that includes all five Central Asian states, with India,
Iran, and Pakistan as observers. Beijing and Moscow are
clearly using the SCO to establish their dominance between the
Pacific Ocean and the Baltic Sea, as evidenced by the joint
Sino-Russian military maneuvers involving 10,000 personnel
scheduled for August 18-25. The SCO is also becoming a vehicle to
keep dangerous democratic ideas out of the region. Moscow and
Beijing appear to have exerted pressure on Uzbekistan and
Kyrgyzstan to send the U.S. military packing, but so far only
Karimov has obliged.
Although the Uzbek move
ostensibly demonstrates the SCO's power, in reality, it
probably has as much to do with Karimov's need for international
protection for his regime. Russia and China are willing to
disregard the human rights violations of authoritarian regimes in
order to draw them into their orbit. Thus, after the Andijan
massacre, Beijing greeted the visiting Karimov with a golden
handshake-a $600 million natural gas contract. Moscow stated that
the repression was an "internal affair" of Uzbekistan and did not
join demands for an international investigation. However, Karimov
will likely wake up one day and find himself being squeezed between
the two giants.
What Should Be
Done. The United States can
continue operations in Afghanistan without K-2. In fact, Defense
Secretary Donald Rumsfeld has already visited Kyrgyzstan and
Tajikistan and has made arrangements for alternative bases. Manas,
Kyrgyzstan, near the capital Bishkek, is likely to take the brunt
of the displaced U.S. cargo air traffic and support missions. Other
U.S. assets will be relocated to the Bagram and Kandahar airfields
in Afghanistan.
Nevertheless, the
United States is still interested in maintaining a presence in
Uzbekistan-civilian and military. First, overflight rights are
important. Second, the Ferghana Valley is a hotbed of Islamist
unrest and needs monitoring. Third, the U.S. Drug Enforcement
Administration wants to maintain a foothold.
To secure its
geopolitical presence in Central Asia, the U.S. should:
-
Expand military,
intelligence, and law enforcement cooperation with the
governments of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan.
The U.S. should
strive to strengthen these countries' military, border guard,
customs, and financial control capabilities, and their ability to
fight radical Islamist and terrorist organizations. Additionally,
the United States should expand training programs for their
military officers in the United States and conduct joint
exercises.
-
Secure regional access
for military activities. Such access will
require a diverse basing infrastructure, including some
redundancy in vital regions. This, along with the correct
technological investments, will ensure that America's ability
to respond to crises will not be compromised by local
politics.
-
Negotiate overflight
rights with Uzbekistan. This can occur if
Karimov is willing to keep the door open to future rapprochement
with the United States.
-
Reach out to a broad
range of political forces and individuals in Uzbekistan.
These should
include members of the Karimov Administration and the spectrum
of moderate Muslims who really care about their country's future.
The U.S. should reiterate that the U.S. and Uzbekistan still share
many common goals, including fighting terrorism and radicalism and
supporting the independence and economic development of
Uzbekistan.
Conclusion.
U.S. interests in
Central Asia are long-term and will not disappear with the
evacuation of the Karshi-Khanabad military base. The U.S.
needs to follow a long-term strategy that includes fighting the war
against terrorism, securing U.S. vital interests, and
promoting freedom in Eurasia's heartland.
Ariel Cohen,
Ph.D., is Senior Research Fellow in Russian and
Eurasian Studies in the Douglas and Sarah Allison Center for
Foreign Policy Studies, a division of the Kathryn and Shelby
Cullom Davis Institute for International Studies, at The Heritage
Foundation. Jack Spencer, former Senior Policy Analyst for Defense
and National Security in the Davis Institute, contributed to
the recommendations in this paper.