Occupied elsewhere, the
United States has let its interest in Latin America slip. Partial
political and economic reforms have failed to realize the expected
progress toward prosperity. As a result, some countries in the
region are turning back toward populism and forging links with
undemocratic adversaries like Cuba, China, and
Iran.
Although the Bush Administration has made
impressive gains in concluding trade pacts and helping the Andean
region combat drug smuggling and terrorism, its policies lack
commitment and a guiding strategy. Growing instability and decaying
quality of life could affect America through declining export
markets, resource constraints, and increased migration to the
north. To regain influence and foster a more prosperous, stable
hemisphere, the United States should revive a strategy of
promoting:
-
Democratic reforms beyond
elections,
-
Open markets beyond free trade,
and
-
Day-to-day collaboration in
fighting transnational crime and terrorism.
Discontent.
All Latin American
countries except Cuba celebrate competitive elections, and most
have adopted some aspects of market economies. Yet citizens now
tell pollsters that they are dissatisfied with democracy,
although they still prefer it to dictatorship. Only 27 percent
believe that markets actually work, although a solid majority
prefer them to state-run economies.
Such responses suggest
partial progress has not produced expected results. Powerful
presidents still impose personal agendas on weak legislatures and
judiciaries, and poorly performing education systems contribute to
poverty and low social mobility. Increased trade helps established
industries and contributes to growth but fails to create jobs
where burdensome regulations and weak rule of law cripple small
businesses.
Looming
Troubles. Expanding populations pose
problems for societies that lack competitive markets. The
population of Latin America and the Caribbean is expected to grow
by 140 million people in the next 20 years. Economies that rely on
exports of raw materials and estate-based agriculture cannot
provide enough new employment to satisfy demand.
Elections have produced a
growing number of left-leaning governments. Brazil, Chile, and
Uruguay are similar to Europe's social democracies. Other
countries are inspired by Cuban dictator Fidel Castro. Venezuela
now features authoritarian rule, restricts liberties, and is
opposed to free trade and U.S. influence. Bolivia's new populist
president might follow suit, and populist-leftist candidates are
running for president in Peru and Nicaragua.
Boosting prospects for
crisis, Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez is buying arms
to scare democratic neighbors such as Colombia and has
announced plans to acquire nuclear technology from Iran. He is also
seeking to unite Latin America in a new energy alliance to
manipulate hydrocarbon sales to the United States and other
nations that he considers adversaries.
Colombia needs to expand
its security forces to force illegal rural armies to demobilize.
President Vicente Fox's attempts to liberalize Mexico's
economy and reform its government have been thwarted by a
divided congress. Mexico and the United States have since reached
an impasse on migrant labor. Instability in Haiti continues despite
peacekeeping forces, a transition government, and recent
elections. Cuba's economy has been strengthened by subsidized
oil from Venezuela, but Castro's death could lead to a breakdown of
order or a massive release of asylum-seekers to the United States,
posing hard decisions for U.S. officials.
An Opportunity
Agenda. President George W. Bush
won congressional approval for trade promotion authority,
concluded a free trade agreement with Chile in 2003, and concluded
a similar pact with the Dominican Republic and five Central
American states (DR-CAFTA) in 2005. Yet U.S. programs to strengthen
democracy have been intermittent, public diplomacy has been
neglected, security assistance to help Colombia to combat
narcoguerrillas lags, and the Administration has no clear energy
policy.
To guard against greater
troubles on America's southern flank, the Bush Administration needs
commitment and a strategy to help neighbors develop societies
in which investments will grow and people will want to live. Its
policies therefore should:
-
Bolster homegrown efforts to improve
governance by strengthening citizen control of political
parties now dominated by founder- owners, establishing links
between legislators and constituent districts, enhancing separation
of powers, and promoting equal treatment of all citizens under the
law.
-
Foster free markets by pursuing pending
bilateral free trade accords with Panama and the Andean
countries of South America. Beyond trade, America should urge
stronger property rights, simpler commercial codes, competitive
banking, and models for privatization that create truly
competitive industries.
-
Improve security through regional
cooperation. To counter today's transnational threats, the
United States should encourage regional partnerships based on
day-to-day military-to-military and law enforcement-to-law
enforcement cooperation.
Conclusion.
Washington needs to
reengage Latin America to offset the influence of Hugo
Chávez and Fidel Castro. Specifically, the United States
should defend principles of free choice in Venezuela, sustain
progress against narcoterrorism in Colombia, support
institution-building in Haiti, develop a post-Castro engagement
plan for Cuba, and promote reforms to move the region's energy
sector away from state ownership and politicization. As Latin
Americans try to sort out their politics, the United States
must help to shape events there in a way that enables hemispheric
neighbors to become more stable and prosperous.
Stephen
Johnson is Senior Policy Analyst for Latin America
in the Douglas and Sarah Allison Center for Foreign Policy Studies,
a division of the Kathryn and Shelby Cullom Davis Institute for
International Studies, at The Heritage
Foundation.