Washington, October 31, 2006-Wartime
recruits who joined the United States military in 2004 and 2005
tended to be better educated and wealthier than their civilian
peers, according to a new report from
The Heritage Foundation.
Economist Timothy Kane studied recruiting information to
determine where service members are from, how much their families
earn and what their education level is. His research follows up on
a similar paper he
wrote last year and shows that the trend toward better-quality
recruits has actually accelerated in the years since 9/11.
This disproves the idea, expressed on Oct. 30 by Sen. John
Kerry, that only those who fail in school end up in the military.
"If you study hard, do your homework and you make an effort to be
smart, you can do well. If you don't, you get stuck in Iraq," the
former presidential candidate told college students.
Yet even "as the conflict in Iraq continues, youth from wealthy
areas continue to volunteer for duty despite increased risk," Kane
says. In fact, the data show recruits from wealthy families are
actually overrepresented in today's military, while the only income
group that's lowering its participation in the military is the
poor. "This evidence suggests that the United States is not sending
the poor to die for the interests of the rich," he says.
Kane, himself an Air Force veteran, broke recruiting information
down by four characteristics: household income, level of education,
race/ethnicity and regional origin.
"Like their peers in 1999 and 2003, recruits in 2004 and 2005
came primarily from middle-class areas," Kane found. In fact, 2004
recruits came from neighborhoods with an average household income
of $43,122. Last year that figure rose to $43,238, more than $2,000
higher than the 1999 average of $41,141 (in constant dollars).
Kane also notes that military recruits tend to be better
educated than the public at large. At least 90 percent of
enlistees, for example, have a high-school diploma, while the
national high school graduation rate is 75 percent. In addition,
"the mean reading level of 2004 recruits is a full grade level
higher than that of the comparable youth population," he
writes.
When it comes to race, "the enlisted ranks are not
disproportionately composed of minorities," Kane found. Whites
serve in numbers almost equal to their percentage of the
population. And while blacks are somewhat overrepresented, "their
representation has decreased during the wartime years and is much
closer to being proportional in 2005 than it was in 2003."