The United States should resolve to help make the world a better
place with initiatives that keep Americans safe, free, and
prosperous in the coming year. Here is a short list of commitments
Washington can offer:
- Finish the Job in Iraq. A stable, secure, and free Iraq
remains a worthy long-term U.S. goal, but this project now rests
primarily in Iraqi hands. However, America still has a vital role
to play in training and supporting Iraqi security forces and
building the instruments of governance for a fledgling democracy.
Meeting these obligations should be the most important factor in
determining the pace of the drawdown of U.S. forces in Iraq.
- Finish the Long War. Rooting out the al-Qaeda
sanctuaries in Pakistan would be a severe--if not fatal--blow to
the transnational Islamist terrorist movement. Achieving that end
will require an integrated policy that gets Afghanistan, Pakistan,
and India working together jointly toward that end.
- Don't Mess with Homeland Security. U.S. law enforcement
has thwarted a number of post-9/11 conspiracies aimed at killing
Americans. Meanwhile, FEMA has just completed a record year of
responding to floods, forest fires, and hurricanes. Further major
reorganization or changes in the Department of Homeland Security's
mission are wholly unwarranted.
- Build Missile Defenses. Of all the threats of the modern
era, the danger of a ballistic missile attack on the U.S. is most
troubling. While the U.S. has built land-based interceptors capable
of dealing with a missile fired from North Korea, much more needs
to be done. America as well as friends and allies in the Middle
East and Europe would be largely defenseless against an Iranian
ballistic missile threat. To address that, the U.S. needs to, as it
promised to NATO, build land-based missile defenses in Poland and
the Czech Republic. In addition, the United States must field land-
and sea-based regional assets, such as the Terminal High Altitude
Area Defense and the Aegis Ballistic Missile Defense systems. More
work also needs to be done on developing "boost-phase" interceptors
capable of knocking down enemy missiles right after they are fired
and are their most vulnerable. Finally, we need to continue, with
our friends and allies, to develop a global command and control
network capable of dealing with new missile threats wherever they
might come from.
- Do Something about Space. Space is the "ultimate" high
ground, not just for the military but for the private sector as
well. U.S. assets and assured "access" to space are vulnerable to
disruption and direct attack. At a minimum, the United States needs
to develop better "space awareness" with hardened and redundant
capabilities to track both what is being sent into space and
activities in earth-orbit. Washington can get the ball rolling by
funding a space-based platform for experimentation this year.
- Worry about Iran. Iran routinely employs terrorism as
instrument of foreign policy. It is developing long-range ballistic
missiles to threaten other nations. It supported insurgents in Iraq
who targeted American soldiers and fermented ethnic-civil war. It
may test a nuclear weapon at any time. For starters, the U.S. must
lead an international coalition to impose the strongest possible
targeted economic sanctions against Iran and mobilize allies to
contain and deter Iran's drive for regional hegemony.
- Build Better Border Security. The Bush Administration
has made significant progress in making America's borders more
secure, from a host of measures for thwarting terrorist travel to
the Merida Initiative--an effort to promote U.S./Mexican
cooperation in combating transnational smuggling in drugs, people,
arms, and money. Terrorists see post-9/11 America as a hard target,
not easy to get to. Meanwhile, both the unlawful population in the
United States and the number of attempted illegal border crossings
are on the decline. Successful programs--from building border
obstacles to enforcing immigration laws and strengthening the
surety of identity credentials like driver's licenses--need to
continue. Stopping now would roll back progress.
- Get Smart on Cybersecurity. Many in Washington have
rightly expressed concerned over the surety of information
technology and control systems that serve our economy. Most,
however, are woefully ignorant about the nature of these systems
and the threats to them. Even as Washington wrestles with issues
concerning organization, authorities, responsibilities, and
programs to deal with cyber competition, it must place more
emphasis on developing leaders who are competent to engage in these
issues. This will require a professional development system that
can provide a program of education, assignment, and accreditation
to develop a corps of experienced, dedicated service professionals
who have an expertise in the breadth of issues related to the cyber
environment. This program must be backed by effective
public-private partnerships that produce cutting-edge research,
development, and capabilities to operate with freedom, safety, and
security in the cyber world.
- Stop Doing Stupid Security. A number of congressional
national security mandates have proven unnecessary and unworkable,
consuming precious time, manpower, and money to implement measures
of little value at great cost. Requirements such as 100 percent
scanning of cargo sent to the United States have been documented by
the Department of Homeland Security and the Government
Accountability Office as extremely problematic. Congress should
repeal ill-advised mandates and refrain from imposing excessive
regulatory restrictions in the name of national security.
- Don't Let the Military Go Hollow. A military is hollow
when it lacks the resources to conduct current missions, maintain
adequate trained and ready forces, and prepare for future threats.
There is no way to prevent the armed forces from becoming
inadequate to defend the nation's interests and provide for our men
and women in uniform other than robust defense budgets year in and
year out. Changes in strategy, cuts in acquisition programs, and
promises to slash fraud, waste, and abuse are all
chimeras--smokescreens to cut costs without appearing weak on
national security. The United States must spend at least 4 percent
of its annual GDP over the next decade to recover from the long
post-Cold War "peace dividend" of the 1990s and refurbish the
military after years of fighting the long war in Iraq and
Afghanistan. To plan to do anything less over the foreseeable
future will put both the nation's security and the lives of our
troops in jeopardy.
James Jay Carafano,
Ph.D., is Assistant Director of the Kathryn and Shelby Cullom
Davis Institute for International Studies and Senior Research
Fellow for National Security and Homeland Security in the Douglas
and Sarah Allison Center for Foreign Policy Studies at The Heritage
Foundation.