Last week, the Press Trust of India reported that defense
officials intend to produce a laser capable of shooting down enemy
ballistic missiles. The United States is a global leader in
directed-energy defenses, including both low and high-powered
lasers. American military research is also highly advanced in the
technologies of acquiring targets as well as the command, control,
and battle management systems necessary to identify and direct
weapons to destroy missiles and other targets. In recent years, the
United States and India have increased bilateral cooperation in a
range of defense, counterterrorism, and homeland security areas.
This cooperation is helping increase trust and confidence between
the two nations while fostering security, stability, and prosperity
in Asia. Working together on directed-energy developments offers a
significant opportunity to strengthen the U.S.-India strategic
partnership.
India Goes to Light Speed
The United States and India share many security concerns, such
as the threat of ballistic missiles. V. K. Saraswat of the Defense
Research and Development Organization rightly told the Press
Times of India: "If you have a laser-based system on an
airborne or seaborne platform, it can travel at the speed of light
and in a few seconds, [and] we can kill a ballistic missile coming
towards [India]." India's Interest in developing directed energy
defenses is understandable, as lasers have several distinct
advantages. Such weapons:
- Can use a high-powered beam of energy to disable electrical
components or detonate explosives, rendering the attack means such
as the warhead or body of a missile useless;
- Come with an almost infinite magazine--as long as the weapons
have power, they can be recharged and fired again;
- Can be aimed effectively using existing target acquisition
systems (such as radars) and command and control systems (such as a
computer battle management network); and
- Can be employed with a minimum of risk toward surrounding
civilians, buildings, or vehicles (such as aircraft, cars, and
ships).
In addition, lasers are versatile. While high-powered lasers
address ballistic missile threats, low-powered lasers have a number
of potential security uses, from disabling small boats to downing
shoulder-fired missiles to intercepting rockets and mortars. All
these uses have application to Indian security concerns.
It is also worth noting that missile defenses, such as
high-powered lasers, limit the potential for regional conflict.
Missile defenses serve as important deterrents, undermining the
effectiveness of enemy threats. They also provide an alternative to
massive retaliation in the face of an actual attack. The security
provided by missile defenses actually limits the likelihood of
armed escalation or an arms race and makes diplomacy more
effective. It is no coincidence that the greatest strides in
reducing the nuclear arsenals came in the late 1980s, at the same
time the U.S. was pursuing the Strategic Defense Initiative. A
world with effective missile defenses is safer and more stable.
American Arsenal
The United States has significant research and development
capabilities regarding the application of lasers for national
security uses. The Tactical High-Energy Laser (THEL) is one such
experimental system tested by the U.S. Army. Development of the
THEL began in 1996 as a joint program between the United States and
Israel to develop a laser system capable of shooting down Katyusha
rockets, artillery, and mortar shells. The THEL system uses radar
to detect and track incoming targets. This information is then
transferred to an optical tracking system, which refines the target
tracking and positions the beam director. The deuterium fluoride
chemical laser then fires, hitting the rocket or shell and causing
it to explode far short of its intended target. More recently, the
Army has experimented with low-power commercial solid-state
lasers.
Another system under development in the United States is the
Airborne Laser (ABL). The ABL is a system that uses a megawatt
chemical laser mounted on a modified Boeing 747 to shoot down
theater ballistic missiles. The megawatt-class laser was first
successfully tested at full power in early 2006. The system is
still under development.
A Shared Security Interest
The American record of military laser research and its many
cooperative ventures with friendly and allied powers suggests that
a joint U.S.-Indian directed energy program is certainly
achievable. The shared interests of both nations in promoting
security and stability in Asia also indicates they have a common
cause in developing military technologies that would lessen the
potential for conflict while effectively countering terrorism. The
U.S. should explore opportunities for joint development of cutting
edge directed energy technologies--lasers--with India as part of
overall missile defense dialogue and deepening of
military-to-military ties.
Lisa Curtis is Senior
Research Fellow in the Asian Studies Center, and James Jay Carafano,
Ph.D., is Assistant Director of the Kathryn and Shelby Cullom
Davis Institute for International Studies and Senior Research
Fellow in the Douglas and Sarah Allison Center for Foreign Policy
Studies at The Heritage Foundation.