Over the past five years, federal spending has leapt
45 percent as lawmakers enacted budget-busting bills on Medicare,
agriculture, education, energy and highways - all while funding the
vital war on terrorism.
Unless Congress gets a handle on spending, within a decade, it will
require a $7,000-per-household tax increase just to balance the
budget. That's on top of the $20,000 per household being collected
now.
Long-term trends are even worse. Within 20 years, Social Security,
Medicare and Medicaid are projected to crowd out every federal
program except defense - which itself would be crowded out by 2045.
The longer lawmakers duck their responsibility to confront
out-of-control spending, the more painful the remedy will be.
There is a path to fiscal sanity that avoids massive deficits and
record tax increases. Congress should freeze nondefense
discretionary spending, rein in runaway entitlements and extend the
tax cuts of 2001 and 2003. The first two measures would help slow
the growth in government spending and avoid the kind of economic
stagnation that plagues Western Europe. Extending the tax cuts will
help keep the American economy the envy of the world.
Step one: Freezing nondefense discretionary spending through 2011
should be a no-brainer. After growing by 43 percent since 2001,
these budgets have room to level off for a few years. There is a
precedent for such restraint, as total discretionary spending
(including defense) was virtually frozen from 1991 through
1998.
Budgets are about setting priorities, and our priorities in today's
dangerous world must be national defense and homeland security.
Congress needs to acknowledge this and ensure that the least worthy
programs take the brunt of the cuts. They should eliminate the $27
billion spent annually on special-interest projects, such as
therapeutic horseback riding, the Baseball Hall of Fame and a
program to curb Goth culture in Missouri - and don't vote for other
spending to take its place.
Capping runaway entitlement spending is absolutely necessary to
avoid European-size tax increases. Over the next decade, annual
Medicare spending will expand by 9 percent, Medicaid spending by 8
percent, and Social Security spending by 6 percent as the first of
the 77 million baby boomers retires. Thus far, Congress has
stubbornly refused to confront this coming crisis. Last year,
lawmakers had to twist arms to pass a reconciliation bill that
merely trimmed short-term annual entitlement growth rates from 6.08
percent to 6.04 percent and did not affect long-term spending
trends. That is not serious reform.
Congress should start by capping farm subsidies at $250,000 per
farm. It should cap federal Medicaid growth at 5 percent per year
and hand it out in block grants to states so they can tailor it to
local needs. It should limit the Medicare drug entitlement to needy
seniors, thus wiping out an unaffordable $8.1 trillion unfunded
liability and begin to transform the Medicare system into one like
the more efficient Federal Employees Health Benefit Program. It
should convert more anti-poverty programs from inefficient handouts
to time-limited benefits that encourage movement toward
self-sufficiency, and it should attack ruthlessly the waste, fraud
and abuse that leads to $40 billion per year in annual program
overpayments.
Finally, Congress must encourage long-term economic growth by
making permanent the tax cuts of 2001 and 2003. In the 11 quarters
before the 2003 cuts took effect, real economic growth averaged 1.1
percent annually. In the 11 quarters since, it has expanded by 3.9
percent annually. Business investment declined for 10 straight
quarters before the 2003 cuts; it has expanded in all 11 quarters
since. Remember the talk of President Bush being the first
president since the Depression to preside over negative job growth?
Five million jobs have been created since the 2003 tax cuts.
Furthermore, low tax revenues are not the problem. Tax revenues are
projected to rise a record $420 billion from 2004 to 2006, and are
near the post-war average of 18 percent of GDP. Investors need to
know that America plans to hold the line on taxes. Besides, history
shows that any new revenues from tax hikes get spent anyway, rather
than pay down debt. We cannot tax our way out of our budget
challenges.
The coming surge in federal spending, resulting mostly from baby
boomer retirement costs, is the single biggest economic challenge
of our era. It's not difficult to see the tough choices that must
be made. Congress simply needs the will to confront these
challenges.
Brian Riedl
is Grover M. Hermann Fellow in Federal Budgetary Affairs in the
Thomas A. Roe Institute for Economic Policy Studies at The Heritage
Foundation.
First appeared in the D.C. Examiner