Members of the U.S. Senate will vote
soon on whether to confirm Utah Gov. Mike Leavitt as Environmental
Protection Agency administrator.
Since being elected governor in 1992, Leavitt has gained the
reputation of being a consensus-builder. He's smart. He's well
liked and respected by those who know him best -- the people of
Utah and his fellow governors.
He has been an influential pioneer in environmental improvement.
With former Oregon Gov. John Kitzhaber, a Democrat, Leavitt
co-authored the Enlibra (from the Latin for "to move toward
balance") doctrine -- eight principles that promote balanced
environmental stewardship. The doctrine has been adopted by the
National Governors' Association, the Western Governors Association
and numerous federal, state, local and private entities.
Leavitt favors cooperative decision-making that involves all
interested parties over top-down directives from Washington. The
approach served him well as co-chair of the Western Regional Air
Partnership -- which developed a multi-state agreement to limit
haze caused by air pollution -- and in his work with other
governors seeking more state control of Clean Water Act
regulations.
In pursuit of cooperative solutions to environmental problems,
Leavitt has consistently rejected extreme dogma. For instance, on
the perpetual expansion of the Endangered Species Act, Gov. Leavitt
wrote: "I support a national effort to preserve selected species,
but our current law … is unmanageable. Do animal rights have
precedence over plant rights? Vertebrate rights over invertebrate
rights? Mammals over fish? Can we take antibiotics as soon as we
feel sick, or do the bacteria have a right to due process?"
Partly as a result of his refusal to cater to extremists of any
stripe, the Associated Press reports, Leavitt "enjoys bipartisan
support from his fellow governors and can expect their help to win
confirmation." The story cites praise from Washington Gov. Gary
Locke and Oklahoma Gov. Brad Henry, both Democrats, as well as
Republican Govs. Mike Johanns of Nebraska, John Hoeven of North
Dakota and Sonny Perdue of Georgia.
And Leavitt's balanced approach does more than win friends. It
produces results. His office reports that Utah now meets all
federal air quality standards, that 73 percent of Utah's streams
meet federal water quality standards (up from 59 percent 10 years
ago and far ahead of the national average of 60 percent), and that
Utah's "concentrated animal-feeding operations," which reduce the
impact of farming and ranching on water quality, have become a
national model.
But none of this will spare him a rough ride through the
confirmation process. Partisan political opponents and
never-say-compromise environmental alarmists seem poised to use
Leavitt's confirmation hearings to put President Bush's energy and
environment policies on trial.
In a hint of things to come, Sen. Joseph Lieberman, D-Conn., a
candidate for president, hotly proclaimed that the Senate should
reject any nominee who "shares the same disregard for clean air,
clean water, land conservation and global warming" as President
Bush. Confirming Leavitt, warned the Sierra Club, would "not
alleviate concerns that the Bush administration is prone to making
shady deals at the expense of a safe and healthy environment." The
Natural Resources Defense Council asserted that confirming Leavitt
"would provide little hope of improvement" for the nation's
environment.
But remember, these groups are hardly mainstream. They look at the
administration's plan to curb wildfires in the west by clearing
brush from the western forests and see nothing but a cynical
pay-off to the timber industry. The administration's effort to
address extensive insect and disease infestation in eastern
forests? Another pay-off. These are people who call natural gas the
"clean fuel," but oppose constructing terminals to receive
it.
In other words, Gov. Leavitt, welcome to Washington. But buckle
up. It's going to be a rough ride.
Charli Coon is an energy and environment analyst at The Heritage Foundation (heritage.org), a Washington-based public policy research institute.
Distributed nationally on the Knight-Ridder Tribune wire