It's a basic tenet of combat: If things are going well, the
campaign plan should remain the same, even if leadership
changes.
Let us hope that axiom holds for the House Committee for Homeland
Security, where Congress has been making some real progress some
real progress Congress has made in getting its homeland security
house in order.
President George W. Bush recently nominated Rep. Christopher Cox,
R-Calif., chairman of the House Committee for Homeland Security, to
head the Securities and Exchange Commission. His successor will
inherit a long to-do list but also a solid legacy of achievement on
which to build.
When Congress created the Department of Homeland Security, it
concentrated on the functions the department would perform and the
agencies that would perform those functions. But Congress did
little to consolidate oversight of the 22 federal organizations and
programs it transferred to the new agency. At one time, 88
different congressional committees could've claimed jurisdiction
over some part of the department's operations. Predictably, the
result was a food fight for power and a stark lack of
oversight.
In 2003, Cox assumed the thankless job of chairing a temporary
select Homeland Security Committee in the House. With no
jurisdiction-and the opposition of other chairs who worked to
undercut the effectiveness of the new committee and to preserve
their own authority-Cox tirelessly made the case for a permanent
standing committee.
His efforts paid off in the 109th Congress, which convened a
permanent House Committee for Homeland Security that has real
jurisdiction and authority. Cox recruited an outstanding group of
committee members, hired a high-quality staff and built a committee
structure, complete with sub-committees focused on the new
department's most pressing issues, such as border security.
The House Committee for Homeland Security also started out with the
right set of legislative priorities. It already has passed its
first-ever DHS authorization bill, an important first step in
ensuring homeland security programs are effective, rational and
accountable to Congress.
Equally important, the committee crafted legislation to reform how
grants are allocated to state and local governments. The
legislation attempts to curb the current practice of just throwing
money at problems to one that addresses high-priority risks and
builds a true national response system.
Both measures have passed the House but await Senate action.
The new head of the committee will find that much remains to be
done. First and foremost, he or she must prevent homeland security
from becoming merely another pork-barrel program, as it has shown
signs of doing. And he or she must build on Cox's commitment to
continue to improve the organization and management of DHS.
Although the Homeland Security Committee doesn't draft the
department's budget, it has an enormous role to play in determining
how the money is spent. The next chair has to share Cox's
commitment to curb ineffective checkbook security.
A strong strain of fiscal conservatism has to be matched with a
spirit of unflinching bipartisanship and immunity to lobbying from
states big and small. Homeland Security is not about making some
Americans safer at the expense of others. It is about solutions
that make all Americans safer. Above all, the new chair must be a
leader, not just a consensus-maker. It's not about getting everyone
in Washington "on board." It's about stopping terrorism.
Homeland security is too important not to be left to the
politicians. We need an engaged and active Congress to play its
role in fighting terrorism, promoting economic prosperity and
preserving liberty. Chris Cox was that kind of leader in the
Congress. The next chair of the homeland security will have to be
one as well.
James Jay Carafano and is a senior legal research fellow for national security and homeland security at the Center for Legal and Judicial Studies at the Heritage Foundation. James is a co-author of " Winning the Long War: Lessons from the Cold War for Defeating Terrorism and Preserving Liberty."
Distributed nationally on the Knight-Ridder Tribune wire