Extremists may insist that Muslims have no choice but to engage
in violent struggle with the West. Last week's election in
Pakistan, however, proves otherwise.
Indeed, the outcome is an important step in countering extremist
ideologies that fuel global terrorism and is therefore good news
both for the region and for the United States. U.S. officials
reacted with guarded praise, but they should welcome the victory of
democratic candidates more broadly and avoid clinging to President
Pervez Musharraf, who for too long has promoted himself as
Pakistan's only savior at the expense of the democratic
process.
The Pakistan People's Party (PPP), which ran on a platform of
countering extremism and bringing stability and modernity to the
country, won the most seats, with another mainstream democratic
party, the Pakistan Muslim League/Nawaz, coming in a close second.
Few likely comprehend the consequences of extremism in Pakistan
more than Asif Ali Zardari, the co-chairman of the PPP and widower
of Benazir Bhutto, who was assassinated by terrorists last
December.
The determination of Pakistanis to participate in the election
despite efforts by al Qaeda and Taliban-backed elements to disrupt
it through violence was itself a victory against extremism.
Terrorists have engaged in a suicide bombing campaign in Pakistan
over the last eight months to avenge last July's military operation
at the Red Mosque and to exploit political uncertainty sparked by
Mr. Musharraf's confrontation with the judiciary. Demonstrating al
Qaeda's designs on Pakistan, Ayman al-Zawahri last summer incited
Pakistanis to jihad over the Red Mosque showdown and proclaimed
that "elections will not save you."
Al-Zawahri has now been repudiated. The election helps end the
serious political instability al Qaeda thrives on and puts the
country firmly on a path toward democratic rule.
Perhaps the most important outcome of the election was the victory
of a secular Pashtun party in the Northwest Frontier Province
(NWFP) over religious parties sympathetic to the Taliban. Although
Mr. Musharraf helped the U.S. in its fight against terrorism in
many ways, he also gave in to the religious parties, backtracking
on promises to rein in local extremists and to close Islamic
schools preaching hatred against the West. The vote in the NWFP
clearly repudiated efforts by extremists to push a strict Islamic
agenda by closing girls' schools, burning video stores, and
threatening barbers - the same tactics the Taliban used to cow the
Afghans in the mid-1990s.
Now that the centrist parties have proven they are more popular
than the religious parties, they should use their mandate to deal
firmly with terrorists, who will never accept the idea of a modern,
economically developed Pakistan engaged with the West. Mr.
Zardari's recent comment that his party would seek negotiations
with militants is troubling. A realistic evaluation of the
situation in the Tribal Areas points to the need for continued
targeted military operations that decapitate the terrorist
leadership and disrupt terrorist plans and operations - not
tactical negotiations that allow hardcore extremists to stay and
thrive. Mr. Musharraf already tried negotiating cease-fires with
some of the militant groups, which only strengthened al
Qaeda-Taliban influence in the region.
A better strategy is to root out religious militancy from the
areas altogether. This will require physically neutralizing
terrorist leaders and ideologues, as well as focusing more
attention on political and economic development of the region. It
will also require closing religious schools that preach hatred of
the West and opening ones that provide more broad-based
education.
The U.S. Congress can spur the process of developing the tribal
lands by moving forward with legislation to create Reconstruction
Opportunity Zones that would provide incentives for investment in
the NWFP by permitting products produced there to enter the U.S.
duty-free.
It's difficult to overstate the importance of this election in
shaping Pakistan's future and how the country deals with religious
extremism. Pakistan's ability to overcome this challenge will
largely determine the ultimate outcome of the struggle against al
Qaeda-inspired global terrorism.
The U.S. image in Pakistan has been tarnished by its unwillingness
to criticize Mr. Musharraf for undermining civil society and the
democratic process over the past year. The U.S. must take the
opportunity to regain the confidence of the Pakistani people by
welcoming these developments and shifting the weight of its support
to the newly-elected civilian government - which represents the
best hope for the country's future.
Lisa Curtis is a
senior research fellow in the Asian Studies Center at the Heritage
Foundation.
First appeared in the Washington Times