In Washington, nothing's certain except death, taxes and
special-interest lobbying groups. So it makes sense that the death
tax has its own lobbyists.
That's right. "Americans for a Fair Estate Tax" knows a Senate vote
is coming soon, and they're hard at work. Their Web site describes
the group as "a coalition fighting to preserve a fair estate tax."
Of course, the name of the group is itself misleading.
There's nothing fair about the estate tax, or as some of us prefer
to call it, the death tax. It hits people at the worst possible
time. Just as they're dealing with the passing of a loved one, they
must settle an estate with the IRS, a process that can be costly.
Many families have been forced to sell their land or shutter the
family business just to pay the death tax, which can seize up to
half of a dead person's assets.
Congress has taken sensible steps to phase out the death tax. It's scheduled to
decline every year until 2010, when it will finally disappear. But
unless lawmakers act to make that permanent, the death tax will
return in 2011 -- at the same high rates that existed in
2002.
So, why would anyone want to protect a measure that makes even
dying a taxable event?
"Americans for a Fair Estate Tax" explains in a set of handy
talking points, available on its Web page. For one thing, it claims
the federal government can't afford to cut the death tax. "We are
facing deficits as far as the eye can see, and Congress will vote
this year on cuts in important programs," the group insists.
Well, Congress often votes on spending cuts. The problem is, it
seldom approves the cuts. Over the last five years, federal
spending has increased 33 percent. So when you get right down to
it, the budget could stand a little cutting.
Besides, the death tax itself carries hidden costs. Heritage
Foundation economist William Beach estimates that the federal
estate tax alone costs the U.S. between 170,000 and 250,000
potential jobs each year. These jobs never materialize because the
investments that would have created them aren't made. By repealing
the death tax, we'd allow the economy to create even more jobs,
which would make all of us better off.
The pro-death tax lobbyists also claim, "Repeal or bad reform of
the estate tax would have a damaging effect on the nation's
charities." But this doesn't pan out, either.
The Congressional Joint Economic Committee reports that charitable
bequests in 2003 reached a record $21.6 billion -- a 25 percent
increase from 1999. And that's with the death-tax rate
declining and set to go even lower in years to come. If
anything, the death tax crowds out charitable giving: The larger
the share of an estate the government seizes, the less money
remains for survivors to support worthy causes.
Finally, the group claims, "A fair estate tax supports the
underlying values of the American dream." Not really. Americans
have always understood the danger of over-taxation and fought
against it.
This country was born out of a tax revolt. In our earliest days,
the Boston Tea Party and the slogan "No taxation without
representation" symbolized our aversion to taxes. Today, even
low-wage earners are willing to hire a tax preparer to make sure
they pay as little as possible. So it's difficult to believe that
Americans support a policy that takes from the dead to feed the
federal coffers.
When the Senate returns, it's expected to consider a measure that
would permanently repeal the death tax. The House has already
passed a similar bill. Senators should do the right thing and put
both "Americans for a Fair Estate Tax" -- and the death tax itself
-- out of business for good.
Ed Feulner is president of The Heritage Foundation
(heritage.org), a Washington-based public policy research
institute.
COMMENTARY Taxes
Keep the Death Tax Dead
Aug 30, 2005 2 min read
Exclusive Offers
5 Shocking Cases of Election Fraud
Read real stories of fraudulent ballots, harvesting schemes, and more in this new eBook.
The Heritage Guide to the Constitution
Receive a clause-by-clause analysis of the Constitution with input from more than 100 scholars and legal experts.
The Real Costs of America’s Border Crisis
Learn the facts and help others understand just how bad illegal immigration is for America.
More on This Issue
COMMENTARY 3 min read
COMMENTARY 2 min read
COMMENTARY 2 min read