Every year, as we wade through hundreds of tax forms and
thousands of pages of regulations, it's hard to believe the United
States is actually a low-tax nation. But for all our faults, we're
light years ahead of many European nations.
And they're doing everything they can to change that-by trying to
drag us down to their level.
One way they want to do that is with the innocent-sounding concept
of "tax harmonization." The idea is to make national borders
unimportant: A Frenchman would be charged his country's
confiscatory tax rates on any money he earned, whether he earned it
in France, the United States, or elsewhere.
This seems like a good plan for high-tax countries like France and
Germany. But it would be a disaster for the United States, and for
individual investors worldwide.
There's about $5 trillion in foreign-owned capital invested in the
U.S. today, including more than $1 trillion deposited in U.S.
banks. Smart investors put their money here because they know it
will be safe (a violent coup seems unlikely), and because our
Congress has made the sensible decision to not tax the money that
foreigners deposit in our banks (the investors get to keep what
they earn).
This money helps create jobs in America-but perhaps not for long,
thanks to a draft IRS regulation that would help foreign
governments tax the interest income their citizens earn on American
investments.
The regulation was slipped in just three days before President
Clinton left office. The Bush administration hasn't implemented it,
but investors remain nervous. They know they could see their tax
bills soar if it takes effect.
There are several problems with this regulation. For one thing,
it's unfair. Income should be taxed based on where it is earned,
not where a taxpayer happens to live.
That simple concept encourages governments to slash taxes to
encourage investment. As my Heritage Foundation colleague Daniel
Mitchell has written, "globalization is making it harder for
governments to overtax, because it is increasingly easy for
taxpayers to shift their productive activities to lower tax
environments." The trend toward lower taxes is something we should
encourage, not stifle.
Also, the regulation is illegal. Federal agencies such as the IRS
are supposed to enforce only those laws passed by our Congress, not
the laws of other nations. And in this case, not only would the IRS
be acting as a tax-collector for foreign governments, it would
actually be ignoring the wishes of our lawmakers, who have
specifically sought to attract money to our economy by not taxing
interest paid to foreign-held accounts.
Finally, the regulation would endanger our economy. Again, one
reason foreign capital comes here is because smart investors
realize they'll be able to pocket their gains. If we start
imposing-or even facilitating-French and German taxation levels,
investors will take their money elsewhere.
That would harm the banking industry. Investment banks currently
hold hundreds of billions of dollars in foreign capital. Imagine
all the money flowing out of our economy overnight to, say, Hong
Kong, where the government maintains a fair, flat tax.
It also would damage our federal treasury. Foreigners hold at least
a third of our debt. If they're forced to pay tax on the interest
they earn here, they won't invest here, and we'd have to find
somebody else to purchase our Treasury bills.
There are plenty of ways that we could improve our tax system. But
"tax harmonization" isn't one of them. If high-tax European
countries want to succeed economically, they should start singing
from the low-tax hymnal-and begin enjoying the growth that goes
along with it.
COMMENTARY Taxes
Siren Song
Dec 31, 2003 2 min read
Exclusive Offers
5 Shocking Cases of Election Fraud
Read real stories of fraudulent ballots, harvesting schemes, and more in this new eBook.
The Heritage Guide to the Constitution
Receive a clause-by-clause analysis of the Constitution with input from more than 100 scholars and legal experts.
The Real Costs of America’s Border Crisis
Learn the facts and help others understand just how bad illegal immigration is for America.
More on This Issue
COMMENTARY 2 min read
COMMENTARY 2 min read
COMMENTARY 2 min read