The normal human reaction to horrendous
disasters such as the one that befell the tsunami stricken areas of
Southeast Asia the day after Christmas is incomprehension. "What
did we do to deserve this?" was the question asked by victims
throughout the countries that were hit. What indeed could any human
have done awful enough to call down such destructive forces of
nature?
Meanwhile, here in Washington the reaction of the press corps can
only be characterized as abnormal, though sadly not surprising.
Rather than report the news, the media focused on fixing the blame.
They took their lead from Democratic critics of President Bush and
U.N. Emergency Relief Coordinator Jan Egeland, who castigated as
"stingy" the initial the pledge of $15 million in U.S. aid
immediately after the disaster.
You might have thought the presidential election campaign had
never finished, and that the media had come up with another reason
for supporting John Kerry. Had President Bush been behind the
curve? Had he already missed another golden opportunity to lead the
world? Why did he not rush home from Christmas vacation at his
ranch in Crawford, Texas. Didn't he care? Before long, something
like "tsunami-gate" was gathering force on the air waives.
So many things are wrong with this reaction that it is hard to
know where to begin. A start might be a reminder that Mr. Bush is
president of the United States, not God. He does not move the
mountains, nor does he command the waves. Mr. Bush was neither
responsible for the disaster nor did even he have the power to
assuage a catastrophe half a world away without warning or
information.
Secondly, the real question was and remains, what can each of us do
to help? How can we mobilize our resources and our charities to
help the victims, their families and communities? The people of
Southeast Asia will not benefit one iota from the hot air and
pomposity infecting the American media.
Interestingly, every single official from Indonesia, Sri Lanka,
India, Thailand or Malaysia who has been interviewed about American
help and cooperation has expressed appreciation and satisfaction
with official American efforts to help -- to the grave
disappointment of interviewers naturally.
The fact is that international aid efforts now underway are
unprecedented in scale. President Bush has promised $350 million in
American public aid, to which should be added the deluge of private
donations that have flowed in on the Internet from American
citizens, over $350 million in just one week. That's the
characteristic American generosity for you. In addition, Mr. Bush
yesterday enlisted former presidents Clinton and Bush in the effort
to raise more from private sources. (Needless to say, suspicions
were immediately aired on CNN that the president was doing this for
political advantage.)
To the funding already promised should also be added the costs of
logistical support underway. Two naval battle groups equipped with
much needed helicopters have been sent to help in the distribution
of aid, of which one quarter of a million tons has already been
dispatched. Some 12,000 U.S. military personnel are now involved in
the largest military operation in the region since the Vietnam
War.
As President Clinton said yesterday when asked the inevitable
question by CNN, whether the Bush administration's efforts were
sufficient, "I don't see how he could have done more."
And let us not forget that Mr. Bush quickly took the lead to
assemble a coalition of our allies in the region for the relief
efforts. Today, military personnel from Britain, Australia, India,
Pakistan and Japan are working with Americans. When it comes to
power projection in the service of international disaster relief,
the world looks to the United States for leadership -- not to
China, Russia or France or other aspiring international
competitors.
It is deeply ironic that the same people who like to complain the
loudest about American global dominance do not hesitate to call on
the United States to deploy its vast military powers when the human
need is there. Only the United States has the air-lift, the
sea-lift and the organizational abilities to meet the enormous
logistical challenges facing the tsunami stricken area.
Meanwhile, here at home, politically inspired critics and media
blowhards should get over their unseemly initial reaction of "blame
the president first." When the world is faced with a humanitarian
crisis of this magnitude, you would think we could rise above
partisan politics and bickering, just for a little while.
Helle Dale is director of Foreign Policy and Defense Studies at
the Heritage Foundation. E-mail: [email protected]
.
First appeared in The Washington Times